CapForge proposed update

A shorter coach card, with traits

Right now a coach is a long list of ratings that look a lot alike. We're thinking about trimming that list and giving each coach a row of traits that say what they're known for.

This is a proposed update to CapForge. None of it is built yet, and your feedback can still change the names, badges and details.

Same coach, shorter card

A sample offensive coordinator's screen today, next to the same coach with traits.

ProposedShorter card, with traits

What goes away

Every coach keeps an overall rating and a scheme. The position-by-position ratings fold into a few broad grades, and the specialties move into traits.

Head Coach

Grades

  • Game Management
  • Culture
  • Scheming

Going away

  • Motivation
  • Discipline
  • Playcalling
  • Play Design

Offensive Coordinator

Grades

  • Playcalling
  • Play Design
  • Passing Game
  • Run Game

Going away

  • Passing
  • Receiving
  • Rushing
  • Run Blocking
  • Pass Protection
  • Motivation

Defensive Coordinator

Grades

  • Playcalling
  • Play Design
  • Front Play
  • Coverage

Going away

  • Pass Rush
  • Run Defense
  • Motivation

Special Teams

Grades

  • Kicking
  • Return Unit
  • Coverage Unit

Going away

  • Motivation

Fourth-down style, blitz frequency, running back approach and rotation style would go away as settings on a coach. Your game plan and playtime settings would own those calls. Traits can make a choice work better or worse, and they never make it for you.

What gets added

Each coach carries up to five badges in a row below their grades. Some are strengths and some are flaws. Many can level up from bronze to gold.

These are just some of them. Dozens more are planned across all four coaching jobs.

Traits that change your roster

A sample from the pool, picked to show the range. Head coaches get the biggest effects.

Trait board
  • Bronze
  • Silver
  • Gold
  • One level
  • Flaw

Plain position boosts

We're also considering simpler traits. A position-group badge gives everyone in that room a flat bump to their OVR while that coach is on your staff.

When a coach gets a point

You pick one of two options: level up a trait the coach already has, or add a new one that fits the coach's style.

Try it. Tap an option on the screen, then confirm.

How a coach picks them up

Arrival

Hired with a few

New coaches show up with what they're already known for.

Level-up

You choose

When one of your coaches gets a point, you pick between two options. Other clubs make their own picks.

The offer

Fits their style

New traits on offer depend on the coach's style and ratings, with some luck mixed in. A West Coast play-caller is more likely to see passing traits.

Over time

Flaws surface

A coach may come with an unknown slot. You find out what it is after they've spent time on your staff.

Traits move with the coach when they change jobs. The same trait on two of your coaches can stack.

What do you think?

Reply wherever you found this page. Short answers help.

  1. Would you miss the position-by-position coach ratings, or is the shorter card better?
  2. Do you want flat position boosts, traits that change how your team plays, or a mix?
  3. Should you pick a coach's upgrades, or should coaches get them on their own?
  4. Are hidden flaws fun, or would they just annoy you when you're hiring?
  5. What's a real coaching habit you'd want to see as a badge?